Moroccanoil texture clay or Shear revival Northern light matte paste

I’m struggling between this one and the northern lights matte paste. Both of these products have nice scent and affordable price in my opinion
I usually go for a quiff and I am looking for a product that lasts long. I have fine asian hair. A little advice will be greatly appreciated.

Also I am looking for good pre-styling product of which I am now considering about the shear revival amity or the antigravity spray by Kevin Murphy. Which should I choose for my case? Or anyone have a better suggestion